Just let me at them. Seriously. I don't mind ignorance. I really don't, but when ignorance fuels snap decisions, I royally get pissed off. Here's the clip that got me steamed.
http://kotaku.com/347350/keighley-sets-mass-effect-record-straight-or-tries-to
This needs to be preserved as a good example how NOT to make judgments and reviews. Every single point they tried to make was wrong. They made assumptions about the game based on what must have been one cut scene, and it's obvious that none of them save the video game expert had even touched the game. Let's break the argument down.
1) This game shows you full digital nudity. FALSE! There is only partial nudity, and when it does occur, it's quick moving side shots, not unlike anything you'd find on primetime TV now. There is no frontal nudity.
2) The person gets to dictate what happens between the them, "if you know what I mean." FALSE! Well, what is it that you mean? Do you mean pushing the X button to simulate pace and rhythm in a sex scene? Ummm...pushing the Y button to change positions? Ummm...pushing the B button to toggle views? If that's what you're thinking your WRONG. The sex scene is a cut scene that you have no control over.
3) The game is rated M for mature but critics say it's being marketed to teenagers and kids. FALSE! Face value. It's rated M. Look on the box. Blood, Language, Partial Nudity, Sexual Themes, Violence, 17+ It's right on the friggin box. This is meant for players 17 and older. If you, mommy and daddy, don't want your kids to play it. Then don't buy it for them. If they decide to buy it on their own, then confiscate it if can. It is your responsibility as parents to decide what your kids should and should not do. That is after all what parenting is right?
4) The damage is that video games portray women as objects of desire, as being of no value other than their sexuality. MAYBE! I'll feign ignorance on this one because I am not a psychologist and do not know what the studies say. However, in reference to the game, it's not like you meet woman and then get a room 5 minutes later. In the game you actually have to develop the romance. You have to talk, God forbid, talk to the characters and make a CHOICE. It's not oh, who do I get to bone next. Each love interest has her characteristics to consider before making the choice. You DO NOT get to have a threesome in the game.
5) And it's a man in this game deciding how many women he wants to be with. FALSE! You can play as a female character and develop a romance with male characters. Yes, for an alien species who can mate with either sex, a lesbian scene is possible, but only if you play as the female character. I find it maddening that when asked if Cooper had played Mass Effect, she giggled it off as if she wouldn't touch it with a 10 foot pole. Obviously, she didn't bother to do some due diligence on how the game could be played. I mean, God forbid that women play video games, and have sexual desires as much as a man does. Umm....Cooper. Do women have the same feelings and desires that a man does? Do women objectify men in their own right?
6) Studies show that boys who play video games cannot tell the difference between what they are playing and the real world if they don't have a real experience. OK! So, you're telling me that if I see sex on video games, I wouldn't be able to differentiate that from sex in the real world? I might buy that. But....then again, by definition, wouldn't I know the difference if I've had the real world experience? You're telling me that if I look at a nice picture book of sex, I wouldn't be able to tell that apart from real sex.....even if I've never had it? Well, even if that were true, isn't that stating the obvious? If I don't have anything to compare things to, then I wouldn't know what is real and what isn't. That just about applies to everything, not just video games. So much for that study.
7) Adult only rating? Once again, you've never played this game. Atari, pinball and pacman? Great games, but so is Mass Effect. You've obviously stopped playing video games a long time ago.....or you've never gone to a Chucky Cheese, ESPN Zone, or Dave and Busters. Old? How about you catch up with the times hmmm? Alright this last one was just outright Ad Hominem, but she had it coming.
I'm completely disgusted with these people. Know your facts before you come to an argument. It's funny to see the moderator "rescue" the psychologist by trying to deflect the fact that she's never played it, and asks the video game expert a psychological question. Way to try to back up your gender there. At least the moderator tried to do some research. None of the other commentators apparently did.
Did they know that you can play the game as a nice, moral character (paragon)? Did they now that you can also play the game as the bad character (renegade)? Did they know that there are dialog choices that need to be made associated with how you want to develop your character? Did they consider the 30 hours or so needed to finish the main story line, and even double that to finish every side quest? Did they realize that the "sex scene" does not happen until the end of the game? Did they realize that little clip that was shown doesn't even happen if you don't choose the right dialog options? Did they do ANY research before blasting this game?
Recent Comments